Isaac James Harvey, 1867–1947
The singer George Spicer, recorded in Sussex in the 1970s, learned a number of songs when working on farms in East Kent in the 1920s and 1930s. Amongst these were songs which George picked up from singers in The Rose at West Langdon, including ‘The Cunning Cobbler’ (Roud 174), which was sung by the landlord, Ike Harvey1. Ike was also related by marriage to another singer, Jack Goodban.
Ike was born on 28th February 1867 and baptised at Ringwould on 14th April. His parents were William Quested Harvey, and Mary Ann Elizabeth Harvey, née Hopper. Their residence was given as Ringwould, but by the time of the 1871 census they were to be found at Lydden Court, Lydden. William’s occupation in 1871 was given as ‘Farm servant’. In 1861 he had been listed as a carter, and in subsequent censuses he was shown as ‘Farm servant indoor’ (1881), ‘Agricultural labourer’ (1891) and ‘Horsekeeper on farm’ (1901).
By 1881, at the age of 14, Isaac was working as a farm servant for Thomas Richards, “Farmer of 159 acres employing 5 men and 2 boys”, at Church Farm, East Langdon. Ten years later he appears to have been temporarily out of work, living with his father in a cottage at West Langdon. He married Louisa Emily Hopper in 1892, and in 1900 moved into the licensed victualling trade: a report in the Dover Express for 20th April 1900, on the previous Thursday’s County Petty Sessions, noted hat “The licence of the Rose Inn, West Langdon, was transferred from Francis Creswell to Isaac Harvey”. The next census, in 1901, listed Isaac as “Farmer & inn keeper”. He and Louisa were by now the parents of four daughters and three sons, between the ages of 0 and 7 years old. They were still running The Rose at the time of the 1911 census, when Isaac’s occupation was listed as “Farmer beer house keeper”. Louisa died in February 1919. She had given birth to another five daughters and three sons, and it is a distinct possibility that she died giving birth to the youngest of these, John.
Their son William had been killed while serving in The Buffs (Royal East Kent Regiment) in the First World War. His death was reported in the Dover Express, 14th May 1915, where it also stated that his younger brother was serving in HMS Inflexible. This younger brother was Thomas George Harvey who, happily, survived his time in the Navy, and lived until he was 59, in 1956.
The Harvey family featured in a police court case reported in the Dover Express, 12th September 1919:
SAD CASE AT WEST LANGDON.
ALLEGED THEFT BY DAUGHTER.
At a sitting of the Dover County Police Court on Monday afternoon, before Mr. A. Evanson, Matilda Mary Harvey was charged with feloniously stealing £25, the money of her father, the landlord of the ” Rose,” West Langdon.
Israel James Harvey, Landlord of the ” Rose ” beer house, West Langdon, said: On Saturday, August 31st, my daughter, who lived at my house and acted as my housekeeper, went out at 7 p.m. with a young man named Pilcher. I thought she was going as far as the next, village, but she did not return, and I did not see her again until I met her in the train to-day at Martin Mill Station. When she left on Sunday she took my child, a little baby, and also the perambulator and some baby’s clothes. On Monday, September 1st, my daughter Ruth missed the clothing, and told me. I then made a search and missed £7 from my private drawer. We then looked to see if the brewer’s money was all right, and then found about £11. 14s. gone. She had also taken some money amounting to about £4, the property of her brothers. I made enquiries, and not being able to find out anything I went to Police Constable Potter, who made further enquiries. On Thursday last I obtained a warrant for her arrest. She had had charge of the brewer’s money and of boys’ money, but had no authority to take it away.
Ruth Esther Harvey, daughter of the last witness and sister to the prisoner, said: On Sunday, August 31st, I was staying next door when my sister left. I did not know she was gone until 10 p.m. on the Sunday. I got up next morning at 7 a.m. at father’s request, and went in and helped to get the little girl up. In doing this I found some of my sister’s clothes had gone and also that some of the baby’s clothes were taken. I told my father, who then went to his private drawer and missed £7. Father then asked me to count the brewer’s money and I found only £5 6s. instead of £17.
Police Constable Harry Kingsland, K.C.C., stationed at Deal, said on Sunday, September 7th, at 3.30 p.m., he found the prisoner detained at, Oxted (Surrey) Police Station. He told her he had a warrant for her arrest on a charge of stealing £25 in money, etc. He cautioned her, and she replied. “I am innocent.” He went to her lodgings with a Mrs. Wallace at 11, Station Rd., East Oxted, and asked her to bring the child and pram to the railway station, which she did. He conveyed the prisoner to Deal on Sunday and to Dover the following day.
The prisoner was remanded till the next Petty Sessions, the father standing bail in the sum of £10 and her own bail of £10.
The following week, on 19th September, the same newspaper reported that the case against Matilda had been dismissed:
REMAND CASE, DISCHARGED.—Matilda Mary Harvey surrendered on bail in answer to an adjourned case from the Dover County Court last week, in which she was charged with stealing £25 from her father, Isaac Harvey, Landlord, of “The Rose,” West, Langdon.
Evidence was read over which showed that the girl absconded from home, where she kept house for her father, with a child of her father’s, a perambulator, and the money. The defendant was in charge of the money but had no authority to take it away. She was arrested at Oxted, Surrey.
Prisoner pleaded not guilty, and after the consideration of the case by the Bench they decided that there was insufficient evidence to send it for trial, and they discharged prisoner.
The “young man named Pilcher” with whom Matilda had stepped out was presumably John Pilcher, whom she married in the final quarter of 1919.
A report on the original hearing in the Whitstable Times and Herne Bay Herald, 13th September 1919, under the headline “GIRL CHARGED WITH ROBBING FATHER”, named the defendant as “Mary Harris”. The daughter in question was definitely Matilda Mary Harvey, born 1895, rather than her younger sister Mary Jane, born 1900. Matilda was still single at the time of this incident, so the surname “Harris” is possibly simply a misprint. Another possibility is that, although unmarried, she had adopted the name of Harris. Her daughter Dorothy Florence Harvey (who would marry Jack Goodban in March 1943) had been born in 1912, when Matilda was 18. In the 1921 census Dorothy’s relationship to John Pilcher is given as “Daughter (father dead)”. Might the unnamed father’s surname have been Harris?
The 1921 census showed Isaac as “Licenced Victualler”, still at The Rose. His daughter Mary – not the one who had stolen money from him – was employed as House Keeper. At 21 years old she was the oldest of his children still at home, and no doubt had her work cut out looking after the eight siblings who also lived at the pub. Of these, the three eldest sons were all out of work. Robert (17) had been working for a farmer by the name of A. Pain, but was currently unemployed; Charles and James (both 15) were both shown as “Pit Lad E Kent Colliery Out Of Work”. The East Kent Colliery was at Tilmanstone, about 31/2 miles away from West Langdon. The Kent coalfields had only been opened up after 1890 and, in the absence of a local workforce with experience of mining, workers were imported from more traditional mining areas including Scotland, Wales and the North of England. The incomers often met with hostility from the local population, and for the most part they remained entirely separate communities. Clearly, however, there were some employment openings for locals lads such as the Harvey brothers – perhaps the mines appeared to present a better opportunity than working on the land, although in the harsh economic climate of the 1920s few industries could guarantee employment.
The Dover Express, 18th October 1929, reported that at a sitting of the Dover Court Sessions the previous day, “The licence of “The Rose,” West Langdon, was transferred from Isaac James Harvey to Frederick George Philpott”. The Rose ceased to be a pub in 1978, and is now a private dwelling. It appears to have been a fairly modest establishment – indeed, up until at least 1889 it had been an off-licence only.2 Ike’s grandson David Harvey recalled that “The bar area was so small that fifteen to twenty customers would fill it comfortably, though I don’t think I ever saw it so full”3.
Ike would have been 62 when he left The Rose and had a bungalow built at Maydensole Farm, about half a mile from West Langdon. Ten years on, in September 1939, he was still living here, at Romany Bungalow, Maydensole. He was now a widower, and described as “Smallholder Retired”. He had managed various plots of land while working as a landlord, and may well have continued to work these following retirement. He died on 27th June 1947, at the age of 80, and was buried in West Langdon churchyard.
George Frampton was in touch with several of Ike’s grandchildren in the 1990s, and they were able to provide details of Ike’s life, including his musical activities – he played a squeezebox as well as being a singer – and could recall the names of some of the songs which he used to sing4. David Harvey said that these were
mainly traditional and folk songs and music hall… Some of his song sheets survived for many years afterwards but, as time went by, they became torn and were disposed of … There were two songs we were able to recall – or at least [his brother] John was – though only pieces of them. One concerned the famous Folkestone Murder… the second is believed to be a Northumbrian song about a butcher who, on his way to market, heard a woman’s cry. After a search, he found the woman, naked, bent over to tend her, whereupon she produced a knife and killed him.
This song would appear to have been a version of the song ‘Three Jolly Butchers’ (Roud 17). David Harvey also remembered
vividly as a boy in the 1930s, listening surreptitiously outside Ike’s door and listening to him talking to himself. The conversation would generally go something like this: “Come on, Ike, give us a song; What would you like? What about …? Right ho.” He would then launch himself with gusto into song and accompany himself on his accordion.
[…]
My grandfather was a complete countryman of Kent. He had a largish moustache which could not escape a pint glass – in my experience, the beer at The Rose… was absolutely awful, but that was not while he was landlord. I have a photo taken in World War I when he grew a beard because his barber went into the army, and he waited for the barber’s return to have it shaved off. Almost until his death, he went ‘home’ to The Rose every Saturday night, and latterly it was my father’s job at 10 p.m. to collect him on one arm, and his bosom pal Jimmy Gregory, a Somerset miner, on the other, and pilot them safely back home, usually the worse for wear. Ironically, my father was a lifelong teetotaller.
Irene Granger, Ike’s granddaughter and sister-in-law to Jack Goodban, described the protocol around singing songs in the pub: “Songs would be sung by the ‘old men’… and nobody else would dare sing another’s song – until one of them died”.
Christopher Whitcomb, another grandson, remembered: “Ike singing his ‘ditties’ to customers and family alike, then lapsing into a mock-Yorkshire accent”. He also recalled, when he was about 6 years old, hearing a song which had the line ‘Jack jumped over the barn with a bundle of sticks’, but this song has not so far been identified.
Songs
- The Cunning Cobbler (Roud 174)
- Blow the man down (Roud 2624)
- The Folkestone Murder (Roud 897)
- The Irish Lass (Roud 44890)
- Three Jolly Butchers (Roud 17)